Nelmar Terrace Homes For Sale

Search Nelmar Terrace homes in St. Augustine FL

Featured below are active Nelmar Terrace homes for sale in St. Augustine, Florida. If you’re interested in a home in Nelmar Terrace that you see below, just click the "Ask a Question" button when viewing the details of that property. Our team is able to provide you with disclosures, past sales history, dates and prices of homes recently sold nearby, and other details related to the Nelmar Terrace real estate market. 

We also invite all St. Augustine, FL home buyers to register for a free account so that you can receive email alerts whenever new Nelmar Terrace homes for sale hit the market, allowing you to stay one-step ahead of other buyers in the area. And remember to call or text us directly with any additional questions you have about buying or selling a home in the St. Augustine, FL area.

Search Nelmar Terrace Homes

Nelmar Terrace Neighborhood Stats

Nelmar Terrace housing market statistics: As of February 21, 2024 there are currently 3 properties for sale in Nelmar Terrace, with an average asking price of $793,000. The highest-priced property is $1,050,000 and the lowest-priced property can be purchased for $579,000. Nelmar Terrace listings have an average price of $497 per square feet, based on listings with 3 beds, 3 baths, and 1,719 square feet of living space.

Nelmar Terrace Neighborhood 

Nelmar Terrace is a prestigious subdivision lined with gorgeous palms and majestic oaks and featuring an assortment of classic architectural styles including Georgia and Dutch Colonial Revival, Mediterranean Revival, bungalow, and even features a Moorish Revival pink castle on May Street. This beautiful historic neighborhood was designated as a National Register Historic District in 2011 due to the high-society residents and historic architecture. The community consists of Magnolia May, and Nelmar streets and ends in a beautiful waterfront park. Close to Vilano Beach, historic Downtown St Augustine for leisurely strolling the cobblestone streets and shopping the quaint local shops as well as dining in some of the finest establishments and enjoying entertainment, Nelmar Terrace is an ideal place to call home! 

The Nelmar Terrace Neighborhood Association protects this beautiful neighborhood from non-residential encroachment as well as strengthens the sense of community within the neighborhood with many social events, creating a welcoming environment for newcomers as well as strengthening bonds between longtime residents. 

Nelmar Terrace community amenities

At the end of Nelmar Terrace is the beautiful Nelmar Terrace Park which offers a scenic vista with walking trails and flower beds. Only a short drive away is Anastasia State Park where you can enjoy camping, bird watching, canoeing or kayaking, picnicking, and miles of nature trails! The park also features a playground, restrooms with shower stations, and laundry facilities. You can rent bicycles, paddleboards, canoes, and sailboats at Anastasia Watersports and grab lunch and drinks at the Island Beach Shop & Grill! 

Nelmar Terrace neighborhood info

Location: Off A1A, near Florida School of the Deaf and the Blind, South of Fullerwood

Zip Code: 32084

Number of Homes:  Approximately 100

Years homes are built in Nelmar Terrace: 1913 - 2017

Square Feet: 1,272 - 4,941

Nelmar Terrace neighborhood schools

Nelmar Terrace is currently zoned for schools listed below but are always subject to change based on school districts being re-zoned.  

Ketterlinus Elementary School

Sebastian Middle School

St Augustine High School

What’s Nearby - Nelmar Terrace community

  • Shopping center with grocery store:  Publix Super Market at Vilano Beach - 2 miles / 6 minutes
  • Drive to the nearest beach:  Vilano Beach - 2 miles / 5 minutes
  • Closest State Park: Anastasia State Park - 3.5 miles / 9 minutes
  • Closest Kayak Launch:  Vilano Causeway Primitive Access - 0.4 miles
  • Closest public boat ramp:  Vilano Public Boat Ramp - 0.7 miles
  • Distance to Historic St Augustine:  0.5 miles / 3 minutes
  • Distance to Jags stadium:  39 miles / 40 minutes
  • Distance to Jacksonville Airport: 49 miles / 50 minutes
  • Distance to the St Johns Town Center:  29.5 miles / 35 minutes
  • Closest Hospital:  Flagler Hospital - 4 miles / 9 minutes

Nelmar Terrace Real Estate Agents

If you are thinking about buying or selling a home in Nelmar Terrace, our team can help you navigate the neighborhood housing landscape and get you the best possible price based on current market conditions. Simply put, we know the Nelmar Terrace real estate market better than anyone!

Contact Brad Officer to see why our Nelmar Terrace real estate agents are the perfect fit for all your home buying and selling needs. And in the meantime, check out our strategy to sell your home here.

Search all St Augustine Real Estate.