Best Neighborhoods in St. Augustine FL

St. Augustine is one of Florida’s most cherished gems, as it is not only the oldest city in the United States, but also an incredibly popular destination for natives and guests alike. St. Augustine contains a wide assortment of unique neighborhoods that each offer their own signature flavor, attractions, and history. Whether you are a lifelong resident or new to the area, these St. Augustine neighborhoods are worth exploring.

Historic Downtown

The heart of St. Augustine, Historic Downtown is where the bulk of the city’s dining, shopping, hotels, and attractions can be found. This region is the oldest part of St. Augustine and some buildings in Historic Downtown date as far back as the 1700s. The neighborhood is extremely walkable and a day spent wandering its streets will take you past beautiful churches, museums, and a number of places to enjoy live music. From Historic Downtown’s bayfront you can take in stunning views of the Matanzas Bay or stroll along the Matanzas River. Historic Downtown is included on the National Register of Historic Places and is accompanied by more than twenty other locations within the neighborhood.

King Street District

King Street is where you’ll find the most unique and eclectic shopping district in all of St. Augustine. King Street features architecture that dates back to the early 1900s, as it was once one of the most bustling business districts for local workers. Today, King Street’s collection of restaurants and shops offer everything from vintage furniture to seafaring essentials. Patrons of King Street can commemorate the occasion with a tattoo or enjoy a meal at one of several family-owned restaurants. With free parking and a collection of retail shops, breweries, and eateries unlike any other part of St. Augustine, King Street District is not one to skip over.


While Lincolnville technically falls within the Historic District, the neighborhood can be considered a treasure all its own. Lincolnville was founded in the aftermath of the Civil War, and the neighborhood became home to many of the area’s most eminent Black professionals and business owners. Today, many of Lincolnville’s countless Victorian homes feature plaques honoring former residents who made a lasting impact on the community as well as the country. Visitors will find that the Lincolnville neighborhood is home to quaint bed and breakfasts and cafes, and offers easy access to the Plaza de la Constitucion, located on the waterfront.

Love the idea of calling St. Augustine home? Get your home search started now and start browsing all active St. Augustine homes for sale or contact Brad Officer, St. Augustine's local real estate expert, for help with all your home buying & selling needs!

Best St. Augustine Neighborhoods To Live


Nestled just beside Historic Downtown, Uptown St. Augustine is known for its historic properties, boutiques, art galleries, and antique stores. Some of Uptown’s most noteworthy attractions include The Fountain of Youth Archeological Park, which is home to the site of the first Spanish settlement in the United States. A walk through Uptown will reveal architecture that dates back as far as the 1800s, and many of the buildings are included on the National Register of Historic Places. There are a number of places for walkers to traverse, and they are likely to discover cute restaurants and hotels along the way.

Anastasia Island

Anastasia Island is fourteen miles long and one mile wide, with the Atlantic Ocean on one side and the Matanzas River on the other. Many of the area’s most stunning beaches are located on Anastasia Island, and the community is also home to a number of hotels, restaurants, and bars. One of Anastasia Island’s most noteworthy landmarks is the St. Augustine Lighthouse, and guests can enjoy live music at the island’s St. Augustine Amphitheatre. Anastasia Island is the ideal place to enjoy outdoor activities, like surfing, kayaking, camping, and fishing.

World Golf Village

World Golf Village was built in the 1990s by the PGA, which built the World Golf Hall of Fame just beside it. The neighborhood offers a blend of large country homes, expanses of land, and world-class golf courses. Two of the area’s most highly regarded golf courses are the King & Bear and the Slammer Squire. Those who spend time in World Golf Village not only have access to world-class golf, but they can also enjoy spas, restaurants, venues for gatherings of all sizes, and an IMAX theater. Golfers who visit the golf clubs also have the option to take advantage of all of the amenities the clubs have to offer.

Posted by Brad Officer on
Email Send a link to post via Email

Leave A Comment

Please note that your email address is kept private upon posting.