The Most Expensive Neighborhoods in St. Augustine FL

Known for owning the title of oldest city in the United States, St. Augustine is a city location on the northeast coast of Florida that attracts new residents and tourists alike throughout the year. Neighborhoods in St. Augustine features stunning architecture, often inspired by the Spanish colonial style, and residents of the area can enjoy easy access to white sandy beaches, like Crescent Beach and St. Augustine Beach. While the majority of neighborhoods in the greater St. Augustine area offer affordable options for home buyers with all different budgets, there are a handful of luxurious communities that are far more expensive, offering residents larger homes with top-shelf finishes and beautifully manicured grounds. If you’re considering a move to St. Augustine and have a higher than average budget, these neighborhoods are certainly worth a visit during your home search. 

Davis Shores

Perhaps most well known for its breathtaking waterfront views of St. Augustine’s Matanzas River, Davis Shores is one of the city’s most elegant communities. The views may be the draw for home buyers, but what truly sets Davis Shores apart is the easy access it proves to the heart of downtown St. Augustine. Homes in Davis Shores feature coastal modern architecture, using neutral tones, natural textures, and chic materials as well as clean, sleek lines. The beauty of Davis Shores lies in the way that homes are so seamlessly integrated into the nature that surrounds them, creating a relaxed lifestyle for all of its residents. Home buyers can anticipate a wide price range for homes within the Davis Shores neighborhood, with prices starting in the high $400s and extending into the low $1M.

Ranch Club at Ashton Oaks

Located just beside Watson Island State Forest, Ranch Club at Ashton Oaks is home to a number of St. Augustine’s most luxurious and opulent residences. Ranch Club at Ashton Oaks is a gated equestrian community made up of 27 estates, which range between 2 and 18 acres each. The community is home to bridle paths and an on-site equestrian center, and contains fenced and landscaped roadways. Home sizes start at approximately 3,500 square feet with some as large as over 6,000 square feet. Home prices also vary, starting at roughly $1M and extending all the way up over $2.5M for larger homes.

Colee Cove Landing

Colee Cove Landing lies just across the St. Johns River from the Bayard Conservation area. The neighborhood is home to a wide array of elegant, luxurious homes that feature various architectural styles. While some homes are available at affordable price points, many of the community’s larger estate homes are some of the most expensive in the area, with prices as high as $7M for homes as large as 6,300 square feet. Colee Cove Landing homes offer residents easy access to the area’s peaceful beaches as well as the nearby Sixmile Creek Preserve and Twelve Mile Swamp Conservation Area. 

Palencia

Situated just outside of St. Augustine’s historic downtown area, Palencia is a gated neighborhood known for its welcoming, warm community atmosphere. Palencia was built across an impressive 300 acres of nature that includes streams, trees, and a gorgeous marsh. Home owners can enjoy all of Palencia’s varied amenities, like a tennis court, swimming pools, fitness center, and an entire system of parks that spans over thirty acres connected by a network of trails for hiking, biking, and walking. Home buyers interested in living in Palencia can expect to pay anywhere from the mid $400s all the way to the $1M to $2M range for estate homes.

Camachee Island

Camachee Island is one of St. Augstine’s premiere neighborhoods and offers residents unmatched views of the Tolomato River and Camachee Harbor. Camachee Island is known throughout the area as being home to some of the best seafood in St. Augustine, and those who enjoy fishing will feel right at home. A day at the beach is only a few minutes away on stunning Vilano Beach, which gives residents access to the Atlantic Ocean. Home prices for a spot on Camachee Island begin in the high $500s, and they go up into the $2M range based on the location and size of the property.